IEC 60599:2022 / IEEE C57.104-20199 min read

Worked Example: Thermal Fault or Tap-Changer Leak? Reading a Mixed DGA Result (T3 / DT)

Transformer TX-101 in the demonstration fleet: ethylene and acetylene both high. How the analyzer separates a hot spot from tap-changer contamination, and why the methods disagree.

Scenario

TransformerTX-101, 132/33 kV, 40 MVA, ONAF, conservator, communicating on-load tap changer, built 2009
Latest sample (ppm)H2 50, CH4 150, C2H6 50, C2H4 270, C2H2 120, CO 380, CO2 3 200
TrendTDCG 349 → 433 → 593 → 1 020 ppm; four gassing events open

Step-by-step calculation

Step 1: IEC 60599 ratios

RatioValue
C2H2/C2H4120/270 = 0.44
CH4/H2150/50 = 3.0
C2H4/C2H6270/50 = 5.4

Step 2: Duval Triangle 1 and Pentagon 1

Step 3: Tap-changer contamination check

C2H2 / H2 (IEC 60599 §5.7)
120 / 50
2.4 > 2 on a unit with a communicating OLTC — probable OLTC contamination

Arcing in the diverter switch produces acetylene with little hydrogen. Oil leaking into the main tank adds acetylene that has nothing to do with the main tank's condition.

Step 4: Weigh the evidence

Ethylene (270 ppm) and C2H4/C2H6 = 5.4 point to a hot spot above 700 °C in the main tank; the acetylene may come partly from the OLTC. The analyzer reports T3 (38 %), DT (26 %), C (17 %), D2 (16 %) and IEEE Status 3.

Step 5: Paper

CO2/CO
3 200 / 380
8.4 — normal band

Result summary

CheckRequirementActualStatus
IEC 60599 Table 1Match a fault rowNo match (mixed)✗ FAIL
Duval Pentagon 1ZoneT3✗ FAIL
OLTC contamination (C2H2/H2)< 22.4✗ FAIL
IEEE C57.104 statusStatus 1Status 3 — Extreme✗ FAIL
TX-101 most likely has a severe hot spot (T3) — a bad joint, core fault or blocked oil duct — but the acetylene may be OLTC leakage. Sample the main tank, the OLTC compartment and the conservators together, subtract the OLTC background, then reduce load and carry out thermography and winding-resistance tests.

Key insight: When methods disagree, check for contamination before diagnosing. On units with a communicating OLTC, C2H2/H2 above 2 in the main tank is a strong sign that some of the gas is not from the main tank.

Try it with your own numbers

Every input in this example is editable in the live calculator — no signup needed.

Open DGA Analyzer (Transformer Oil) calculator →

Frequently asked questions

Why does Triangle 1 say DT but Pentagon 1 say T3?

The pentagon uses five gases including H2 and C2H6, so it separates thermal faults better; the triangle uses only CH4, C2H4 and C2H2 and is pulled towards D by the acetylene.

What is TX-101-LTC in the fleet?

The tap changer of TX-101, entered as its own asset. Comparing its DGA with the main tank is how OLTC contamination is confirmed.

More in Transformers, CT/VT & Condition Testing

← Back to all worked examples