IEEE 80-20137 min read

Why Substations Use Crushed Rock: Tolerable Touch Voltage With and Without a Surface Layer

Part 4 of the earthing series. The same grid fails without crushed rock (limit 289 V) and passes with 100 mm of it (limit 932 V). How the surface layer factor Cs works.

Scenario

SoilUniform, ρ = 200 Ω·m
Grid50 m × 40 m, buried 0.6 m, conductor diameter 12.6 mm, 20 rods of 3 m
FaultEarth fault 5 kA, split factor Sf = 0.6, Df = 1 → grid current IG = 3 kA
Clearing time0.5 s, 70 kg body weight
Layout5 m mesh (11 × 9 conductors) from Part 3 — mesh voltage Em = 822 V, step Es = 680 V

Step-by-step calculation

Step 1: Without a surface layer

The person stands on native soil, ρs = ρ = 200 Ω·m, so Cs = 1.

E touch = (1000 + 1.5 ρ) × 0.157/√0.5
E touch = (1000 + 300) × 0.222
E touch = 289 V; E step = 489 V

Step 2: With 100 mm of wet crushed rock (3,000 Ω·m)

Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − ρ/ρs)/(2hs + 0.09)
Cs = 1 − 0.09 × 0.933/0.29 = 0.710
E touch = 932 V; E step = 3,061 V

Step 3: Compare with the grid

CaseEm (V)Touch limit (V)Es (V)Step limit (V)
No surface layer822289680489
100 mm crushed rock8229326803,061

Result summary

CheckRequirementActualStatus
Touch, no surface layer≤ 289 V822 V✗ FAIL
Step, no surface layer≤ 489 V680 V✗ FAIL
Touch, crushed rock≤ 932 V822 V✓ PASS
Step, crushed rock≤ 3,061 V680 V✓ PASS
Without a surface layer the grid fails both touch and step limits. A 100 mm layer of crushed rock raises the touch limit from 289 V to 932 V, so the same grid becomes safe.

Key insight: Crushed rock does not change the voltages the grid produces — it adds resistance under the person's feet, so they can tolerate much more. It must be kept clean; soil or sand mixed in lowers its resistivity.

Try it with your own numbers

Every input in this example is editable in the live calculator — no signup needed.

Open Earthing Grid Design (IEEE 80) calculator →

Frequently asked questions

What resistivity should I assume for crushed rock?

Use the wet value. IEEE 80 lists typical values from about 1,000 to over 10,000 Ω·m depending on the stone; 3,000 Ω·m is a common design value.

Does asphalt work the same way?

Yes. Asphalt has a very high resistivity and is often used for roads inside substations.

More in Earthing, Lightning & Static Safety

← Back to all worked examples